← All guides

Cost model 11 min read

Which forum software is cheapest long term for a growing site?

Sticker prices tell you little about year three. This guide breaks forum costs into the parts that grow, the parts that stay flat and the parts nobody lists, then gives you a worksheet to run with your own numbers.

The Jetonomy admin dashboard showing community totals inside WordPress

Most forum cost advice stops at the price on the pricing page. That number matters, but it is rarely the number that hurts. What hurts is a bill that scales with a thing you want more of, such as members, or a cost that was never on the page: the evenings you spend on updates, the fee to move away, the add-on you only discover you need in month eight.

This guide does not quote prices, and that is on purpose. Vendors change their plans, and a number copied here would be wrong by the time you read it. What lasts is the shape of the cost: what each kind of forum software charges for, what grows when your community grows, and what hides behind the sticker. Once you know the shapes, you can pull the current numbers from each vendor yourself and fill in a worksheet. That is the last section.

If you want the quick version: a flat cost beats a growing one the longer you stay, a cost you can control beats one you cannot, and your own time is a cost in every option. The rest of the guide shows how to check that against your situation.

Why a three-year view

Year one flatters hosted platforms. You sign up, you pay a small first-tier plan, and nothing needs installing. Year one also flatters free self-hosted software, because you have not yet paid for the first emergency update or the first spam wave.

Year three is where the shapes separate. By then your membership is larger, your content is an asset you would rather not lose, and the cost of leaving has grown with it. A three-year window is long enough to show the slope of each cost, and short enough that you can still guess your own growth with some honesty.

Pick a growth guess before you read on. Not a hope, a guess. If you have run a community before, use the members you actually gained last year. If you have not, use three cases: you stay where you are, you double each year, and you grow ten times. Cost shapes behave very differently across those three, and that is the whole point.

The six pricing shapes

Almost every forum product charges in one of these ways, and many combine two. Learn to name them and a pricing page becomes easy to read.

1. Per member or per seat

You pay for each person. Sometimes the unit is registered members, sometimes active members in a month, sometimes seats for staff or moderators. The definition of the unit is where the money is. A plan that counts every account ever created behaves very differently from one that counts only people who logged in this month.

What grows: the bill moves in step with your audience. Good growth is penalized, and so is a clean-up of dead accounts only if the vendor counts active members.

What to ask: what exactly counts as billable, whether guests who only read are counted, and what happens when you cross a limit mid-month.

2. Tiered plans

You pay for a plan, and each plan has a ceiling: members, spaces, admins, storage, features. The cost looks flat until you hit a ceiling and the next step up is not small. The ceiling you hit is usually not the one you were watching. People watch the member count and then trip over a feature gate, such as single sign-on, API access or custom branding.

What grows: nothing, until it jumps. Plan the jump. If you expect to cross a ceiling in the second year, price the plan after it, not the one you start on.

What to ask: which features sit on which tier, and whether the thing you rely on today is on the tier you are pricing.

3. Hosted plan with the vendor running everything

You pay a recurring fee and the vendor handles servers, updates, backups and uptime. This is what you are buying when you choose Circle, Mighty Networks or hosted Discourse. It is a real service, and for many teams it is the correct purchase.

What grows: the plan tier, and sometimes per-member charges on top. What does not grow: your admin time, which stays small. That is the trade.

What to ask: what happens to your data if you stop paying, and how you get an export that another system can read. You can see how this plays out in our comparison with Circle and Mighty Networks.

4. Self-hosted app on its own server

The software is free or has a licence, but it needs its own machine and its own upkeep. Discourse is the best-known case: a Ruby application with its own database, mail setup and update routine. NodeBB and Flarum run on their own stacks as well. You pay for a server, usually monthly, plus the hours to keep it healthy.

What grows: server size as traffic grows, and the hours spent on upgrades, backups and security. It also grows in a way people forget, which is the need for a person who can fix it at an awkward hour.

What to ask: who on your team can restore the server from a backup, today, without looking it up. If the answer is nobody, price in a managed host or a support contract.

5. Plugin licence plus hosting you already have

The forum is a plugin on a site you run anyway. You pay a licence for the plugin, or nothing for the free ones, plus a share of the hosting you already pay for. bbPress, wpForo, Asgaros and Jetonomy sit here. Jetonomy’s free plugin runs a complete community and a paid Pro licence adds extensions, limited by number of sites and not by number of members.

What grows: hosting, slowly, as traffic grows. Licence renewal is a flat line. The extra cost of the community on your host is often small until the community is large, and a good host plan covers it.

What to ask: what you lose if you skip a renewal. With Jetonomy, for example, an expired Pro licence stops Pro features and updates, and the content stays yours in your database. Check that behavior for any licence you price.

6. A cut of your transactions

If you charge members, some platforms take a percentage of each sale, on top of whatever the payment processor takes. This is the shape that is easiest to miss because it does not show up until you start earning, and it scales exactly with your success.

What grows: with revenue. A community that makes ten times the money pays ten times the cut.

What to ask: whether any fee applies on top of the payment processor’s, and on which plans. Self-hosted software and plugins do not sit in the payment path, so they cannot take a cut. With Jetonomy the checkout belongs to your membership or store plugin, and Jetonomy reads the entitlement to open or close a space. We cover that split in how to monetize a WordPress community.

What grows when your community grows

Here is the useful way to look at it. Cost lines fall into four groups, and each group responds to growth differently.

Grows with members. Per-member fees, active-member tiers, storage for uploads and, on self-hosted setups, server resources. If you can only watch one number, watch the lines in this group.

Grows with activity, not members. Moderation time, email sending volume, search and database load. A small, noisy community can cost more to run than a large quiet one. Spam also lives here. A forum with open sign-up and weak anti-spam turns into a part-time job, whatever it cost to buy. The anti-spam options and trust levels in the software you choose are cost features, not just safety features, because they decide how many hours you spend deleting junk.

Grows with revenue. Transaction cuts and any plan tier tied to what you earn.

Stays flat. A licence with a site limit, a fixed hosted plan below its ceiling, and the cost of a domain.

A good long-term pick has most of its cost in the last group and a small slice in the first. A poor one has the bulk of its cost in the first group, because that is the one you are trying to enlarge.

The costs nobody puts on the pricing page

These show up in year two and three, and they are why a cheap option can turn out expensive.

Migration

Leaving costs more than joining. You need to move topics, replies and users, keep old URLs working, tell members where you went and win back the ones who do not follow. Some of that is software time and most of it is human time. If the old system exports to a standard format, the technical part is small. If it does not, it can be large enough to keep you where you are for another year, which is the lock-in working as designed.

You can read what a real move looks like in how to migrate to Jetonomy from bbPress, wpForo or Asgaros and in the guide on moving from Discourse to WordPress. Two things are worth taking from those: importers save days and manual rebuilds cost weeks, and the cost of leaving is something you should price before you arrive.

Moderation time

Moderation is the largest cost in a successful community and it never appears on an invoice. Count it in hours per week at your current size, then decide how it changes at five times the size. Tools that let trusted members help, set posting limits for new accounts and queue risky posts reduce the hours, which makes them a financial feature. See how trust levels and moderation work in Jetonomy as one example of this approach.

Lock-in

Lock-in is the price of leaving, paid in advance by every month you stay. It comes in three kinds. Data lock-in means you cannot get a complete export. Audience lock-in means your members have accounts on someone else’s platform and your list of them is partial. URL lock-in means your search rankings belong to a domain you do not control. Self-hosting on your own domain removes the third kind entirely and reduces the other two.

Add-ons and integrations

The base price covers the base product. Then you want single sign-on, a membership gate, email digests, a mobile app, analytics. Each may be another plan tier, another paid plugin or another service. List the add-ons you will need by year two and price them now. For Jetonomy, the free plugin gates spaces with MemberPress and Paid Memberships Pro, and a Pro licence adds more gating integrations and extras. It is the same exercise for any product you compare.

Downtime and recovery

A hosted platform includes uptime in the fee. A self-hosted setup does not, and an outage in your busiest week costs you members you never get back. Price a backup routine and a tested restore. Test the restore at least once; an untested backup is a hope, not a plan.

Your time

Give an hour a price. Even if you do the work yourself and never pay anyone, the price is what that hour would earn elsewhere. Then count the hours: setup, updates, moderation, member questions, the odd emergency. The people who say a free option costs nothing are counting the licence and skipping the hours.

Where each option is the better pick

A cost guide that always ends with the same answer is advertising. These are the cases where something other than a WordPress plugin wins on cost.

A small, stable community with no website. If you have no WordPress site and no plan to build one, a hosted platform on a low tier can cost less overall than a host plus a plugin plus the time to set both up. Nothing to maintain is worth real money when the audience is a few hundred people.

A very large standalone public forum. Discourse has years of hardening at that scale and a mature plugin ecosystem. If you have people who run Ruby infrastructure, or you are happy to buy its hosting, it can be the right spend. Our Discourse comparison goes through the trade honestly, including where it is stronger.

A community that is mostly a product. If courses, live events and native apps are what you sell and you want them in one hosted bundle, a platform such as Circle or Mighty Networks charges for that convenience and delivers it. The Circle comparison lists what you get for the money.

A team with no appetite for maintenance. If nobody on the team wants to run updates, hosted wins even when it costs more in cash, because it costs less in attention.

A community that lives next to a WordPress site. If your members already log in to a WordPress site, for a store, courses or a membership, then a plugin avoids the second server, second login and second bill. That is the case Jetonomy is built for, and it is where a flat licence on hosting you already pay for tends to come out ahead over three years. The pricing detail lives on the pricing page, where current figures belong.

A worked example, with no numbers

Take a hypothetical course business with a WordPress site and a growing student base, comparing three routes. Follow the logic of the cost lines, not any figure.

Route A: a hosted community platform. Setup is quick. Cost lines: the plan, which steps up as student count passes tier limits; a second login for students; possibly a transaction fee on course sales sold through the platform; and a rebuild if you ever leave. In year one it is the simplest. In year three it is the one whose bill moved most, because it is tied to the audience you grew.

Route B: a self-hosted forum app on its own server. Cost lines: a server, a mail service, an hour or two each month of updates, a person who can restore from backup and a single sign-on bridge so students use one login. Cash cost can be modest. The cost that bites is the bridge, because it breaks when either side updates.

Route C: a plugin on the existing WordPress site. Cost lines: the licence if you want Pro, a slightly bigger host plan as traffic grows, and the hours to configure it once. Students already have accounts, so there is no second login. Checkout stays with your store plugin, so there is no cut. The risk is that the plugin does not do something a dedicated platform does, such as native mobile apps from the vendor. You weigh that against the savings.

Notice what decided the comparison. It was not the headline price. It was which lines scaled with students, which lines depended on a person’s availability, and which carried a fee on revenue. That is the pattern to look for in your own case.

The worksheet

Copy this into a spreadsheet. Fill one column per option you are seriously considering. Pull every price from the vendor’s current page on the day you do this, and note the date.

Inputs, once for all options

  • Members now, members at end of year 1, year 2, year 3 (use your three growth cases)
  • Revenue you expect to take through the community each year, if any
  • Your hourly value, for your time and for a freelancer
  • Hours per week of moderation now, and your estimate at 5 times the size

Per option, per year (year 1, 2, 3)

  1. Licence or plan fee at that year’s member count (read the tier or per-member rule carefully)
  2. Add-ons you will need by that year
  3. Hosting or server share (zero if it is included, or if it rides on a host you already pay for)
  4. Transaction cut on the revenue input (zero if the vendor is not in the payment path)
  5. Setup hours in year 1, update and backup hours each year
  6. Moderation hours each year, adjusted for the tools the option gives you
  7. Single sign-on or integration upkeep, if there is a second login
  8. Support or managed-host cost, if nobody on your team can run the stack

Once per option

  1. Cost to leave: export format, redirect work, and the hours to bring members along
  2. Cost of a failure: what an outage of a day costs you, and what recovery needs

Add lines 1 to 8 per year, multiply the hours by your hourly value, sum three years and add line 9 as a one-time exit cost. Then run the sheet for each of the three growth cases.

Two checks make the sheet honest. First, look at which column changes most between the “stay the same” case and the “ten times” case. That option is the one most exposed to your success. Second, set the hourly value to zero and rerun it. If the winner changes, your answer depends on whether your time is free, and you should say that out loud to whoever approves the budget.

How to read the result

If one option wins in all three growth cases, you are done. If the winner flips as growth rises, you are choosing a bet, and the useful question becomes how likely fast growth is.

Look at the gap, not just the order. A win by a few percent over three years is a tie; pick on features and fit. A win by a wide margin is worth taking even if the winner needs more of your attention, as long as you have the attention.

Check one more thing: how the result moves if the vendor changes the price. A flat licence you control is predictable. A plan on someone else’s platform can change under you, and your cost to leave, which you already priced, is what limits your response. That is a risk worth a line in the budget notes.

Where Jetonomy fits, and where it does not

Jetonomy is a plugin, so it belongs to the fifth shape. The free plugin runs forum, Q&A, ideas and feed spaces and imports from bbPress, wpForo and Asgaros. Pro adds extensions on a licence limited by site count, not by member count. It does not bill per member, and it takes no cut because it never touches your payments.

It does not remove all costs. It runs on your WordPress host, so a very large community needs a host that can carry it, and an expired Pro licence stops Pro updates. It also does not ship the hosted extras a platform such as Circle bundles. If you want to try it before you price it, you can add a forum to WordPress on a staging copy and judge the effort yourself, which is an input to the worksheet.

The point of the worksheet is to make that kind of judgement from your own numbers, not ours.

Common questions

Which forum software is cheapest in the long run?

It depends on how fast your member count grows and how much of your own time you count as money. Software with a flat licence and a host you already pay for tends to win as membership grows, because its cost stays level while per-member or tiered plans keep climbing. A small, stable community on a free hosted tier can still be cheaper than anything self-hosted.

Is there forum software that does not charge per user?

Yes. Self-hosted software such as phpBB, bbPress, Flarum, NodeBB, wpForo and Jetonomy does not bill by member. You pay for hosting and, for some of them, a licence or paid extensions. Hosted platforms more often price by member count, active member, seat or plan tier, so read the plan rules for what counts as a billable person.

Is there forum software that does not take a cut of my sales?

Self-hosted forums do not take a cut because the vendor is not in the payment path. Jetonomy is one: your own membership or store plugin handles the checkout and Jetonomy only reads who has paid. On hosted community platforms, check whether a transaction fee applies on top of the payment processor's own fee, since it varies by plan.

Is free forum software really free?

The licence may be free, but running it is not. You still pay for hosting, backups, a security routine and the time to update it. For a WordPress plugin on a site you already run, the extra hosting cost is often close to zero. For a separate app on its own server, it is a real monthly line item plus admin time.

Does switching forum software later cost a lot?

It can cost more than a year of licence fees. The expensive parts are moving the content, redirecting old URLs so search traffic survives, and getting members to adopt the new place. Choosing software that exports cleanly and keeps your data in a database you control lowers that cost.

How should I count my own time in the cost?

Give an hour a price, even if it is only what you would pay a freelancer, and multiply by the hours the setup, updates and moderation take each month. People skip this step and then compare a free option against a paid one that includes the work. Moderation time is the one that grows fastest, and it applies to every option.

Do I need Jetonomy Pro?

Not to run a complete community. The free plugin includes forum, Q&A, ideas and feed spaces, membership gating with MemberPress or Paid Memberships Pro, importers and the REST API. Pro adds extras such as reactions, messaging, analytics, AI moderation and more gating integrations, under a licence that is limited by site count, not by member count.

Build it on your own WordPress.

Jetonomy is free to start and self-hosted. Run the 5-minute wizard and put what you just read into practice.

What customers say on Trustpilot

WBCOM Designs is Amazing!

WBCOM Designs has constantly updated and supported their plugins and themes. Recently the new BuddyNext project is Amazing! - and the new line of addons like Mediaverse, Jetonomy, Mediashield, and Listora.. are likewise Amazing! - and very well built. Today their online Chat solved a download…

Edward S.US